
We all have one.
The one who your heart belonged to for so long, yet went unrequited.
Mine was, and will always be *Henry*.
When I was a Freshman in college and unsure of what I wanted to major in, I decided to give Theater a go.
Since I was 3 years old, I proclaimed to the world that I was going to be an Actress.
Not “If” but “When”
I took a few classes and was asked by a senior to be in one of his student films.
I was more than excited.
The film was about two college students who try to go on a date and hi-jinx ensue. I swear, I don’t even remember what it was about (and I was the lead). It was a silent film exercise so there was no dialogue. Cant blame me for not remembering.
Most of my scenes were set in the cafeteria, and that is where I was to met the “director” and the rest of the crew.
After arriving on my first day on set, there he stood, a classmate of the director.
His name was *Henry* and he was there to help his fellow classmate with anything he needed. He was the star pupil and did what he could to help others.
In the few hours that we spent together, I learnt that besides for being adorable (and not in a conventional movie star sort of way) he was Swiss. He had the most dreamy french accent. He was an aspiring film maker and I was a sucker for artists.
Henry was 4 years older than me, and his brother and Parents all moved to Israel the summer prior. He was Jewish and brought up conservative (like me)! He even spoke fluent Hebrew.
That was all I needed to hear.
I was already wondering what we were going to name our children.
I decided that I was not going to leave that night without exchanging numbers- and we did.
I ran home and called my best friend Franny and proclaimed “I have met the man that I am going to marry.”
Henry and I became fast friends.
The emphasis being on the word- FRIENDS.
He never tried anything romantic on me, and for a VERY long time I wondered whether or not he batted for another team. I mean, he never spoke of women .. or men for that matter.
I met Carlos, one of his good friends and I spilled my heart out to him. I asked him what Henry’s deal was. He too was puzzled. When my gay best friend met him, he said his Gaydar (which is totally almost 100% dead on) went off. I said that it wasn’t that Henry was gay, he was just European.
One day, Henry called me up and asked if I wouls help him. He was doing his student film and his actress backed out on him last minute. He wondered if I could replace her.
Anything for him I thought.
Anything.
So I agreed.
The shoot was filmed outside his home, and went on all night. He asked if I wanted to sleep over.
Y to the E to the S
“Sure” I said.
When he was shooting the other actor, I was upstairs in his apartment snooping.
What would I be able to find?
Other than some suspicious looking potato bread that was in his fridge, I went into his bedroom and found a stack of pictures.
Nothing incriminating either way.
Just then the phone rang.
Me: “Hello?”
Voice on line: “Hi, can I speak with Henry?”
Me: “He’s shooting his film downstairs, but should be up soon”
Voice on line: “OK, tell him that his girlfriend called”
And thus began my descent into darkness.
GIRLFRIEND?
What girlfriend is this?!?
We had been friends for almost a year and never a mention of a girlfriend.
At least he wasn’t gay, I thought.
Then suddenly, as if a curtain had been lifted from over my eyes- I noticed a photo on the wall.
HENRY AND HIS GIRLFRIEND.
Oh great.
Wonder-fucking-ful.
When I went back down, I let him know she called- but he was too busy working.
That night, after the shoot wrapped, we sat on his couch and drank some cocoa and talked for hours.
He told me about his girlfriend and how they were often on/off.
If he wasn’t going to try anything then, he was never going to try anything.
And he didn’t.
And that was it.
For years I pined for him.
It was though he was blissfully unaware.
A part of me felt like he did like me, but was holding back.
Or maybe… he JUST WASN’T THAT INTO ME.
I mean, not everyone is going to feel for you the way you feel for them.
That’s just life.
I myself ended up finding someone who actually loved me.
Henry finished up his degree and moved to California.
Until this day, we speak every few months or so.
He is such a genuine person, and has become quite successful in Hollywood.
Love hasn’t been so kind to him, and a girlfriend who he adored ( a sometimes dancer on DWTS) left him when she found out he was sick and needed to go through months of treatment.
He is still undergoing treatments and surgeries for his ongoing condition.
I hurt for him when he told me this.
He is a VERY good man.
I told him he needed to find someone who would love him and be with him through it all.
I truly hope he finds that special someone one day- just as I have found mine.
I am proud to call him a friend.
*Names have been changed to protect the innocent*
Question: Do you ever think about “The one that got away” ?







amy d said
I still have dreams of my high school boyfriend. He was my first love and best friend. I adored him. He did the worst thing imaginable and cheated on me with my best friend at the time. Needless to say, we broke up, I moved away for college out of state, and don’t have any contact with him to this day.
But every so often I will dream of him. I’m usually chasing him like a pathetic puppy dog and he is ignoring me. I wake up angry.
I’ve never told anyone about this! EESH!
AmazingGreis said
The “LOVE” of my life is Justin Timberlake!
*swoon
And one day he’ll decide, “To hell with the Hollywood actress types!” and he’ll come find me. I just know it!!!
Ok, so all psycho stalker dreams aside, I had just a “friend” who I fell head over heels for. He is a great guy and any girl would be lucky to have him, but I guess he never felt anything for me. He moved away, but I think about him all the time. We text occasionally and I see him when he’s in town, but that’s about it. I’m still a little sad about it. But I know one day I’ll find “that” guy…hopefully soon, cause I’m not getting any younger!
rach said
I think we all need that one to remind us of how far we’ve come. Mine was so amazing, a great guy, who was clueless to what I felt throughout high school, but once in college he got really drunk and tried to kiss me. His heart had just been broken, so as much as it killed me…I did not kiss him back! He will be at my wedding with his wife and 3 kids. I never even think about my crush until I see him, but I still remember analyzing the most insignificant comments looking for a sign…lol.
Pudyqat said
Yeah, I had a high school/college boyfriend that I also chased like a pathetic puppy dog for three years. We were together whenever his parents allowed it, which wasn’t ofen. Even though we lived on the same street, I lived “on the wrong side of the tracks”. His mother was convinced I was corrupting her darling son. Not a single thing she accused us of doing was true (and she thought of everything). Finally I had enough and moved far away. THEN he got mixed up with some baddies and got into drugs, drinking, smoking — you name it. Then his PARENTS decided I wasn’t so bad and decided I should come back home. But by then I was engaged to someone else and declined respectfully (?). I loved him dearly (and I guess I still do in a way) but I know we would never have made it in the long haul. My life turned out great. His? Not so much. So I lost the battle but won the war, I guess.